MEDIA: VOA Hindi radio service to be shut down

Voice of America's Hindi radio service is on the chopping block. As you will see below from the message that's been circulated by those who work there, radio service will cease on September 30, 2008 (it was first launched in July 1955). About six staffers will lose their jobs. The website and a once-a-week, seven-minute segment on Aaj Tak, a television channel in India, will continue. A senior VOA official (who wouldn't talk on the record to SAJAforum) told me that how the web and TV presence will evolve will be decided after the radio service stops running. I have a call into other officials, seeking on-the-record comments and will update this post as necessary. If you have thoughts, comments, etc, please post it in the comments section below. Tips, leads, welcome, too: saja[at]columbia.edu

[Update: Commenter "ex-VOA" writes below:

Unfortunately, VOA Hindi TV programs are mostly celeb or bubblegum stories while VOA Radio addressed the most pressing and pertinent political and social issues for the 'common man' in India. Many of their listeners were rural, uneducated but grateful that someone was paying attention and lending an ear to their voice. RIP.

Bruce Barker, former VOA editor, writes in the comments section below:

I was friends with many of the Hindi service writers, translators and broadcasters. They are a highly professional group of news people. VOA Hindi has been relied upon by millions of listeners in India and by Indians living and working elsewhere in South Asia. BBG has wasted millions of US dollars to concentrate on Board members' favorite pet projects, all at the expense of the only truly reliable service the United States has to reach massive audiences all over the world. The Hindi service is just one of the most recent examples. This is one reason that some of us in the VOA Central Newsroom referred to VOA as DOA. ]

In the message below, Ashok Sarin of VOA Hindi Service (Radio) - akumarsarin[at]yahoo.com - asks those interested to write to members of Congress who might be able to influence this decision.  He concludes by writing: "Even writing a letter to Wall Street Journal, New York Times and Washington Post can serve a useful purpose."

You will be sorry to know that the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG) has announced to the employees of the Voice of America , Hindi Service (Radio) that their broadcasts will be abolished on September 30, 2008.  This decision was presented as being the "will of the Congress".  However, in December the FY 2008 funding bill for the Broadcasting Board of Governors, which was PASSED by both houses and signed by the President, directed that this proposed cut be REVERSED.

On July 16, 2008, the House Appropriations Subcommittee on State, Foreign Operations and Related Programs marked up the Broadcasting Board of Governors FY 2009 budget and again directed this proposed cut be REVERSED.  Excerpts from their recommendation:

<>Language Service Reductions - The Committee recommends sufficient funding in fiscal year 2009, including $8,000,000 provided in Public Law 110-252, the Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2008, to maintain broadcasting in languages which the BBG proposed to reduce or eliminate.  The Committee supports an ongoing effort to improve audience reach by utilizing the most effective means of transmission; however, the Committee does not support going silent in many critical regions.

It appears that the Broadcasting Board of Governors is ignoring the will of the Congress.

 

Hindi is the flagship and national language of India .  There are severval million muslims in India (more than the population of Pakistan,  who keenly listen and ask questions about US strategic partnership with India and its efforts in the Middle East .  All Hindi VOA Radio Listeners depend on VOA Hindi Radio programming and news to keep themselves fully informed and this is one of main reasons that in a recent survey 73 per cent people gave U.S. the most favored nation status.

President George Bush has already launched an initiative to promote foreign languages in American schools including HINDI.  U.S. is shifting more diplomats to India while reducing the numbers in Europe, boosting attention to the rising power and importance to India .  The entire U.S. business is working on "India Strategy", but BBG is not thinking straight.  Indo-US nuclear deal, India cooperation in the reconstruction of Iraq and Afghanistan , joint military exercises and several other issues figure prominently in Indo-US relationship which is going to be extremely substantial in the years to come.

The Urdu Service of VOA for Pakistan, Dari and Pashto Services for Afghanistan, have been extended by several hours a day while the Hindi Radio Broadcast to India is only an hour a day and that too is likely to be eliminated.  Shutting the Hindi Radio will be an insult to the people of India .  Radio is the only medium to reach all the 750 million Hindi speaking people of India.

Given the strategic importance to India as the world's largest democracy, a de facto nuclear power, world's fifth largest economy and an important ally of the united States in the WAR AGAINST GLOBAL TERRORISM, shutting down the well established daily Hindi Radio programming since July 1955, should not be favored.

  I will urge you to please take this matter up with the members of India Caucus and other members of the Appropriation Committees of both the U.S. House of Representatives and the Senate, plead with them that they advise BBG Chairman and other members of the Board NOT to close down VOA Hindi Radio Service.
Some strong action is needed and I am hopeful that you will help us in our mission.

Regards,
Ashok Sarin,  Voice of America, Hindi Service
akumarsarin@yahoo.com

Key  appropriation committee members who can stop the Hindi Radio cuts:

1. Representative Chris Van Hollen, Jr., U.S. House of Representatives, 1707 Longworth House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215    Fax: 202-225-0375

2. Representative Donna Edwards, U.S. House of Representatives, 2470 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215     Fax: 202-225-8714

3. Representative Steny Hoyer, U.S. House of Representatives, 1705 Longworth House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215.   Fax: 202-225-4300

4. Representative Roscoe Bartlett, U.S. House of Representatives, 2412 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215.  Fax: 202-225-2193

5. Representative Frank R. Wolf, U.S. House of Representatives, 241 Cannon House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215.  Fax: 202-225-0437

6. Representatives Thomas M. Davis III, U.S. House of Representatives, 2348 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215. Fax: 202-225-3071

7. Representative Robert J. Wittman, U.S. House of Representatives, 1123 Longworth House, Washington D.C,. 20215.  Fax: 202-225-4382

8. Representative James P. Moran, U.S. House of Representatives, 2239 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20215. Fax: 202-225-0017

9.  Hon. Howard Berman, Chairman, House Committee on Foreign Affairs. Fax 202-225-3196.

10.  Hon. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Ranking Member, House Committee on Foreign Affairs  Fax: 202-225-5620

11.  Hon. Nita Lowey, Chairman, House Committee on Appropriations, Fax: 202-225-0437

12.  Patrick Leahy (Appropriations Subcommittee - State, Foreign Relations and related Programs. Fax: 202-224-3479

13.  Senator Jim Webb (Appropriations Subcommittee) Fax: 202-224-4024

MEMBERS OF INDIA CAUCUS

1.  Jim Mcdermott, 1035 Longworth  HOB, Washington D.C. 20515. Phone: 202-225-2452  Fax: 202-225-2455

2,  Joe Wilson, 212 Cannon House Office Building, Washington D.C. 20515. Phone: 202-225-2452  Fax: 202-225-2455

3.  J. Crowley, Phone: 202-225-3965

Besides, India lovers like Palone and others can also provide help. It will be a good idea to send faxes to almost all the above personalities.  Even writing a letter to Wall Street Journal, New York Times and Washington Post can serve a useful purpose.

We need help.
Your Friends at VOA, Hindi.

Comments

[ALOKESH GUPTA]

Can we have the email id's of the persons mentioned above instead of Postal addresses & Fax numbers so that can take up the issue with fellow shortwave listeners here in India.

Regards
Alokesh Gupta
New Delhi.
+ 91-9818449395

[ex-VOA]

I used to work at VOA so this is sad news though not unexpected. The VOA and BBG management have been pouring money into television at the expense of radio. Unfortunately, VOA Hindi TV programs are mostly celeb or bubblegum stories while VOA Radio addressed the most pressing and pertinent political and social issues for the 'common man' in India. Many of their listeners were rural, uneducated but grateful that someone was paying attention and lending an ear to their voice. RIP.

[Bruce Barker]

As a former South Asia Regional News Editor in the Voice of America Central Newsroom, I can tell you first hand from the mail that the VOA Hindi service was one of the most popular language services broadcast by The Voice. The BBG obviously continues its merciless dismantling of VOA radio broadcasting. Including English. I was friends with many of the Hindi service writers, translators and broadcasters. They are a highly professional group of news people. VOA Hindi has been relied upon by millions of listeners in India and by Indians iliving and working elsewhere in South Asia. BBG has wasted millions of US dollars to concentrate on Board members' favorite pet projects,all at the expense of the only truly reliable service the United States has to reach massive audiences all over the world. The Hindi service is just one of the most recent examples. This is one reason that some of us in the VOA Central Newsroom referred to VOA as DOA.
Bruce Barker
Writer / Editor, Voice of America News, Washington D.C. (Retired)

[bijay singh,sr.journalist]

its really bad to know the vlosure of voa.it should not be closed and no one has right to shut down the voice of people.
voice of america hindi channel should be continue

[hindivoiceover]

Its sad to know that VOA Hindi radio service is about to end.I am sure there be many people who will miss this interesting radio feed & probably cant record their displeasure in any online forums.

[Arthur Dudney]

Here's an article from the Washington Post that cites Indians' experiences with VOA's Hindi service: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/11/AR2008091103305.html?wpisrc=newsletter

[mediamovers]

Indeed a sad moment...Lamho ki tanhai ab sirf reh gayi hain ab hamara pass.

[Prashant]

VOA is one of the good & reliable radio station i used to listen during my school days in my rural hometown along with BBC Radio Germany.Many farmers have been listening the news so i can tell alone in one district of maharashta 8 lakh will miss VOA so in overall Maharashtar 8 * 40 = 32000000 people will miss VOA.In india 32000000*40=12,80,00,000 people will miss VOA.
So USA will lose the reach to millions of people by closure of this service.

[UTPAL DUTTA]

Dear Sir,
I am a regular listner of voice of america.Its news is so good that every people easily attract in this station.Its Hindi and Bengali broadcasting is also good.
sir ,my name is utpal dutta.I have done B.sc.(math hons) in 2006.I am from jamshedpur(INDIA) Iwant to be a part of voa.as a news reader or a collecting news(repoter).so, If you offer or getting me a chance.I can join this station without any salary. Here is my Mob.NO:+0919234969711.

[ashishdimri]

Dear Prof Sree,
VOA Hindi service is popular for its english language teaching.
Many ESL teachers recommend its lessons.
It is a sad news!
yours sincerely,
ashish dimri