IMMIGRATION: Illegals from India to the U.S.

The U.S. government released a report on Friday, Aug. 18, 2006, about illegal immigration, putting the estimated number of illegals at 11 million at the start of 2006. The full report, from the Office of Immigration Statistics in the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (the renamed INS) - in turn a part of the Department of Homeland Security - is available as a PDF here:
http://www.uscis.gov/graphics/shared/statistics/publications/ILL_PE_2005.pdf.

While most illegal immigrants come from Mexico and other countries south of the border, the country with the highest percentage change is India, with a 133 percent growth in illegals between 2000 and 2005, the period covered by the report. India is #4 in the total numbers (after Mexico, El Salvador, Guatemala), with no other South Asian country in the top 10 or mentioned in the seven-page report. India now accounts for about 3 percent of the illegal population.

India has 280,000 illegals in 2005, up from 120,000 in 2000, accounting for about 2.6 percent of the total, up from 1 percent. By contrast the percentage of U.S. citizens of Indian origin as a total of the U.S. population is less than 0.7 percent (if you count 2 million out of 300 million).

The top 10 countries are (with their 2005 and 2000 numbers):

• Mexico (5.9 million/4.6 million)
• El Salvador (470,000/430,000)
• Guatemala (370,000/290,000)
• India (280,000/120,000)
• China (230,000/190,000)
• Korea (210,000/180,000)
• Phillipines (210,000/200,000)
• Honduras (180,000/160,000)
• Brazil (170,000/100,000)
• Vietnam (160,000/160,000)

Interestingly, the opening lines of the report say:

Estimating the size of the unauthorized population living in the United States is challenging  because of data limitations. There are no national surveys, administrative data, or other sources  of information that directly provide accurate estimates of this population. As a consequence, the  unauthorized immigrant population must be estimated by making certain assumptions and by  combining data that measure events with those that measure populations.

Here are links to some stories on this topic.

Do you have a reaction to this? Know of further analysis? If so, please use post in the comments section below. Requires one-time, free registration. After that, you never need to register on SAJAforum.org again!

[Thanks to Sendhil Revuluri for help with some of the calculations for this story.]

Comments

[Sendhil]

I wonder whether people of Indian origin are also overrepresented among "authorized immigrants", such as permanent residents and visa holders. I suspect that's the case, and in that case this might be a more legitimate comparison than just counting citizens.

[K.N.Gupta]

Shocking but not alarming as other countries are not far behind .
K.N.Gupta

[Sam Weerahandi]

Based on my own samples ( I often chat with people I meet in China town and India town), I do not believe that there are more illegal immigrants from India than from China. In fact chances are that there are more Indonesian illegal immigrants than Indian illegals.

[Jaya Kamlani]

Fleeing to U.S., Cubans' First Stop Is Often Mexico
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/16/world/americas/16cuba.html?th&emc=th (full story)

CORTÉS, Cuba — Cubans are migrating to the United States in the greatest numbers in over a decade, and for most of them the new way to get north is first to head west — to Mexico — in a convoluted route that avoids the United States Coast Guard… Cuban authorities contend that the migration is more economic than political and is fueled by Washington’s policy of rewarding Cubans who enter the United States illegally.

In fact, unlike Mexicans, Central Americans and others heading to the southwestern border of the United States, the Cubans do not have to sneak across. They just walk right up to United States authorities at the border, benefiting from lax Mexican enforcement and relying on Washington’s “wet foot, dry foot” policy, which gives them the ability to become permanent residents if they can reach United States soil.

Jaya Kamlani